RESUMEN
Introducción. El dolor lumbar es una de las causas más frecuentes de consulta y discapacidad en pacientes, y según su evolución temporal se puede clasificar como agudo, subagudo y crónico. Objetivo. Estimar en pacientes con Dolor Lumbar Subagudo (DLS), la eficacia de un programa de ejercicio comparado con antiinflamatorios no esteroideos (AINES). Métodos. Se realizó un ensayo clínico controlado aleatorio, con enmascaramiento simple en 90 pacientes y DLS con o sin radiculopatía, 46 pacientes fueron asignados a un programa de ejercicio físico y 44 a tratamiento con AINES. El desenlace primario fue la mejoría del dolor y los secundarios mejoría en la función, calidad de vida, ausentismo laboral y depresión con seguimiento a 1, 3 y 6 meses. Resultados. Al mes, no se registró diferencias en el dolor entre los grupos de 8,16 (IC 95 % -2,19 a 18,51), sin embargo, en el grupo de ejercicios hubo una mejoría de 47,3 (SD: 19,8) a 28,8 (SD: 20,5), p <0,001, y en el grupo de AINES de 45,2 (SD: 22,6) a 34,9 (SD: 25,0), p = 0,018. Otras muestras de mejoría se observaron en la función medida por el Índice de Discapacidad de Oswestry (ODI), la cual mejoró al mes en el grupo de ejercicio (p<0,001), mientras,la función física también mejoró al mes en el grupo de ejercicio (p= 0,038). Otra mejoría se observó en el dolor, función y calidad de vida que se mantuvo a los 3 y 6 meses en ambos grupos. Finalmente, La recurrencia fue mayor en el grupo de AINES: 25,5 % vs. 7,1 % (p= 0,04) al mes; 25,5 % vs. 7,1 % (p= 0,04) y 20,5 % vs. 5 % (p= 0,04), a los 3 y 6 meses. Conclusión. El ejercicio supervisado fue más efectivo que los AINES para disminuir la discapacidad y las recurrencias y mejorar la función física en pacientes con DLS.
Introduction. Low back pain is one of the most frequent causes of consultation and disability in patients, and according to its temporal evolution it can be classified as acute, subacute and chronic. Objective. To estimate the efficacy of an exercise program compared to non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) in patients with subacute low back pain (LBP). Methods. A randomized, single-masked, controlled clinical trial was conducted in 90 patients and DLS with or without radiculopathy, 46 patients were assigned to a physical exercise program and 44 to NSAID treatment. The primary outcome was improvement in pain and the secondary outcomes were improvement in function, quality of life, work absenteeism and depression with follow-up at 1, 3 and 6 months. Results. At 1 month, there was no difference in pain between groups of 8.16 (95 % CI -2.19 to 18.51), however, in the exercise group there was an improvement from 47.3 (SD: 19.8) to 28.8 (SD: 20.5), p <0.001, and in the NSAID group from 45.2 (SD: 22.6) to 34.9 (SD: 25.0), p = 0.018. Other signs of improvement were seen in function as measured by the Oswestry Disability Index (ODI), which improved at 1 month in the exercise group (p<0.001), while physical function also improved at 1 month in the exercise group (p= 0.038). Another improvement was observed in pain, function and quality of life which was maintained at 3 and 6 months in both groups. Finally, recurrence was higher in the NSAID group: 25.5 % vs. 7.1 % (p= 0.04) at 1 month; 25.5 % (p= 0.04) at 1 month; 25.5 % (p= 0.038) in the exercise group (p= 0.038) at 1 month.
Asunto(s)
HumanosRESUMEN
Background and Aim: Knowledge translation processes are necessary for improving patients' and communities' health outcomes. The aim of this study was to systematically develop evidence-based recommendations for people over 16 years of age who are in risk for or have suffered a lower limb amputation for medical reasons (vascular, diabetes mellitus) or trauma (civilian or military trauma) in order to improve function, quality of life, decrease complications and morbidity. Methods: Following the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) approach we developed a Clinical Practice Guideline (CPG) for lower limb amputees with funding from the Ministry of Health in Colombia and participation of a multidisciplinary group. We included patients' preferences. Based on the scope, purposes and objectives the questions were elaborated with the PECOT strategy. The evidence search was performed for each question in the main databases: Cochrane Library, Embase and PubMed, without time limit or language restriction. Teams were formed with thematic experts and clinical epidemiologists to review the clinical studies, describe the evidence, and evaluate the quality of the body of evidence with the GRADE methodology. The recommendations were made according to the judgments proposed by the GRADE working group. We conducted a stakeholder's dialogue as a mechanism for the external validation of the guideline implementation. Results: The CPG included 43 recommendations related to the diagnosis, surgical treatment, rehabilitation, prescription and adaptation of the prosthesis. They were strong in favor 37.2, weak in favor 53.5, strong against 2.3, Weak against 7.0%. Quality of evidence was high in 0, moderate in 11.6, low in 58.1, and very low 30.2%. Discussion: In 93% of the recommendations, the quality of the evidence was between low and very low. This is why it was so important to validate and discuss each recommendation with an expanded multidisciplinary group. The research group identified 25 interventions and five milestones to be prioritized in the implementation and in the stakeholder's dialogue participants identified opportunities and barriers for implementation of recommendations. Conclusion: It is necessary to develop a national policy for implementation strategies of CPG recommendations that promotes the necessary arrangements for the provision of services for diagnosis, treatment, and rehabilitation of individuals with amputations.
RESUMEN
Resumen Objetivo: Presentar el estudio mediante el cual se construyó una ruta integral de atención en salud (RIAS) para la atención del paciente amputado de miembro inferior por causas traumática, vascular o diabetes mellitus, cuyo fin es implementar las recomendaciones de la Guía de práctica clínica del paciente amputado y garantizar la atención integral en salud de esta población en Colombia. Con la ruta se pretende orientar a los actores involucrados en la ejecución de intervenciones individuales para el diagnóstico, el tratamiento y la rehabilitación, e impactar en los desenlaces en salud y equidad de esta población. Metodología: Este estudio responde a una estrategia de mejoramiento de la atención en salud. Para esto, se revisó el Manual metodológico para la elaboración e implementación de las RIAS; se creó el grupo desarrollador de la ruta; se priorizaron y describieron las intervenciones en función del proceso continuo de atención en salud; se evaluó la práctica asistencial actual con grupos focales de pacientes y profesionales; se formularon los resultados esperados en el proceso de gestión y atención en salud (hitos), y se elaboró el diagrama de la ruta. Resultados: A partir de la Guía de práctica clínica se elaboraron 25 intervenciones individuales priorizadas y caracterizadas según el actor responsable, la población objetivo y el entorno. Para cada una de las intervenciones se presentan resultados esperados en salud, calidad de prestación de servicios, aspectos relacionados con la equidad, y la perspectiva de pacientes y actores involucrados con la atención. Se construyeron los indicadores para el seguimiento e implementación de la ruta. Conclusión: Se construyó la primera ruta integral de atención en salud del paciente con amputación de miembro inferior, de acuerdo con los lineamientos del manual del Ministerio de Salud y de la Protección Social.
Abstract Objective: Build an Integral Health Care Pathway for the care of patients with lower limb amputation due to traumatic, vascular or diabetes mellitus causes, in order to implement the recommendations of the cpg for amputee patients and guarantee comprehensive health care for this population in Colombia. Methodology: This study is a strategy to improve health care. Carried out by a review of the Methodological Manual for the Development and Implementation of Comprehensive Health Care Pathway, then the development group was created. A process of prioritization and description of required individual interventions was developed based on health care. Evaluation of current care practice with focus groups, formulation of milestones and development of the intervention diagram. Results: 25 individual interventions were prioritized and characterized according to the responsible actor, target population and environment. Expected results in health, quality of service delivery, issues related to equity, as well as the perspective of patients and actors involved with care are shown. Indicators were built for monitoring and implementation of the pathway. Conclusion: With the previous results, the first Integral Health Care Pathway for the Lower Limb Amputee Patient was developed. It intends to guide the actors involved, when executing individual interventions for the diagnosis, treatment and rehabilitation, to impact outcomes in health and equity of this group .
Resumo Objetivo: Construir uma Rota de Atenção Integral à Saúde do Paciente Amputado do Membro Inferior por causas traumáticas, vasculares ou diabetes mellitus, com a finalização de implementar as recomendações do gpc do paciente amputado e garantir a atenção integral na saúde desta población em Colômbia. Metodologia: Este estudo responde a uma estratégia para melhorar os cuidados de saúde. Foi realizada uma revisão do Manual Metodológico para o Desenvolvimento e Implementação de Rotas Integrais de Atenção à Saúde, criação do grupo de desenvolvimento da rota. Um processo de priorização e descrição das intervenções individuais necessárias foi desenvolvido com base na continuidade dos cuidados de saúde. Avaliação da prática assistencial atual com grupos focais, formulação de marcos e desenvolvimento do diagrama de intervenção. Resultados: 25 intervenções individuais foram priorizadas e caracterizadas de acordo com o ator responsável, população-alvo e ambiente. Determinação dos resultados esperados em saúde, qualidade da prestação de serviços, questões relacionadas a equidade, bem como a perspectiva de pacientes e atores envolvidos no atendimento. Foram construídos indicadores para o monitoramento e implementação da rota. Conclusão: Com os resultados anteriores, foi construída a primeira Rota de Atenção Integral à Saúde do paciente com amputação de membros inferiores por causas traumáticas e neurovasculares, com sua implementação, visando orientar os atores envolvidos na execução de intervenções individuais para a diagnóstico, tratamento e reabilitação, impactar os resultados em saúde e eqüidade dessa população.
RESUMEN
BACKGROUND: The issue of lower extremity amputation has been in the Colombian political agenda for its relationship with the armed conflict and antipersonnel mines. In 2015 the Colombian Ministry of Health published a national clinical practice guideline (CPG) for amputee patients. However, there is a need to design implementation strategies that target end-users and the context in which the CPG will be used. This study aims to identify users' perceptions about the barriers and facilitators for implementing the guideline for the care of amputee patients in a middle-income country such as Colombia. METHODS: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 38 users, including patients, health workers, and administrative staff of institutions of the health system in Colombia. Individuals were purposively selected to ensure different perspectives, allowing a balance of individual positions. RESULTS: According to participants' perceptions, barriers to implementation are classified as individual barriers (characteristics of the amputee patient and professionals), health system barriers (resource availability, timely care, information systems, service costs, and regulatory changes), and barriers related to clinical practice guidelines (utility, methodological rigour, implementation flexibility, and characteristics of the group developing the guidelines). CONCLUSIONS: Our study advances knowledge on the perceived individual and health system barriers and facilitators for the implementation of the CPG for amputee patients in Colombia. Importantly, the governance, financial, and service delivery arrangements of the Colombian health system are determining factors in implementing CPGs. For example, the financial arrangements between the insurance companies and the health care provider institutions were identified as barriers for the implementation of recommendations related to the continuity and opportunity of care of patients with amputations. The design of implementation strategies that successfully address the individual behaviours and the contextual health systems arrangements may significantly impact the health care process for amputee patients in Colombia.
